Shareholder disputes

Getting into business is a lot like getting married, and it’s pretty similar when things go wrong. A lot gets lost in the emotional fallout of a shareholder dispute – you might feel hard-done by, there might be ruined friendships and wasted time. You might not even be on speaking terms.

It’s pretty hard to strike a deal to part ways when emotions are running high and there’s money involved.

You might need a valuation, but you probably don’t. You probably just need some help negotiating, and cutting through the emotion.

What has value?

For larger businesses you might need a valuation to agree a price, because there’s more at stake. Getting to the core of the dispute often identifies other levers that we can pull to get an outcome, and different things have value to different people.

Usually, money isn’t even the most important thing, and a high level valuation opinion is all you need. Especially if all parties are experienced in and involved in the business, they will have an idea of what the business is worth.

Getting to an agreement

Usually, shareholder disputes crop up because of a lot of little things, and that last little thing has pushed someone over the edge. You know you need to go your separate ways, but you can’t agree on what that actually means.

The outcome is usually the same. Someone buys someone else out. But the process can be very different depending on what’s caused the dispute. Sometimes you’ll be willing to burn the village down to save it. Sometimes your business is your baby and you absolutely must protect it at all costs.

Pulling some of these levers and maybe even splitting the business up can often get a better outcome than just crunching the numbers.

The key questions are, what does success look like to you,
and can we help you get there?

Getting someone else to crunch the deal

Sometimes the best thing you can do is remove yourself from the situation, and have someone else step in with the high level parameters of an acceptable deal outlined.

This is especially true if you’re at the point where you hate each other’s guts and want to just move on. Sometimes, you’ll want to remove yourself from the situation even if things are not at that level. Especially if you value the friendship and think it can still be saved.

Getting someone to represent you in a negotiation means there’s much less of a chance that you’ll make an irrational decision and either ask for too much and derail things, or ask for too little and sell yourself short.

Ending up in court

If things have already gone too far and it’s not going to settle out of court, we are able to put together evidence for you. This could be preparing a valuation (or set of valuations), helping define commercial aspects of the tradeoff, critiquing another valuation, or a bit of everything. We will sit in the witness box if needed.

Next steps

If you need a bit of help pulling together ideas of how you’re going to get yourself untangled from your fellow shareholders, we’re happy to have a confidential, complimentary catch up to see if we’re a good fit.

Just get in touch by filling out the enquiry form below, or contact the team directly.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Joshna Mistry

Partner and Value
Added Services Lead.
Read Joshna’s profile.

Humphrey Hart

Senior Analyst and
Entrepreneur.
Read Humphrey’s profile.

As a client Gilligan Sheppard you will have access to international networks and resources to enable optimal outcomes for your business / trust / transaction. xero logo It’s small business accounting software that’s simple, smart and occasionally magical. Log in online anytime, anywhere on your Mac, PC, tablet or phone to get a real-time view of your cash flow. 
As a client Gilligan Sheppard you will have access to international networks and resources to enable optimal outcomes for your business / trust / transaction. tax traders logo Tax Traders allows you to buy someone else’s tax to settle your account with Inland Revenue, as well as save on interest and late payment penalty charges.
As a client Gilligan Sheppard you will have access to international networks and resources to enable optimal outcomes for your business / trust / transaction. smart ar logo Astute cash flow management is essential for operating a small business.
As a client Gilligan Sheppard you will have access to international networks and resources to enable optimal outcomes for your business / trust / transaction. myob logo Trusted by 1.2 million businesses, myob is New Zealand’s largest accounting solutions provider. The platform is equipped to support the needs of New Zealand organisations.
As a client at Gilligan Sheppard you will access to international networks and resources to enable optimal outcomes for your business/trust/transaction.  accountancy insurance logo Tax Audit Insurance specifically designed for accountants in public practice. This provides cost effective protection and peace of mind against the substantial cost that may be incurred should IR or other government authorities conduct a random review, investigation or audit.
As a client Gilligan Sheppard you will have access to international networks and resources to enable optimal outcomes for your business / trust / transaction. cpa logo A CPA is a finance, accounting and business professional with a specific qualification. It indicates a soundness in depth, breadth and quality of accountancy knowledge and gives you competitive advantage over your peers.
As a client Gilligan Sheppard you will have access to international networks and resources to enable optimal outcomes for your business / trust / transaction. agn international logo AGN International is a worldwide asociation, composed of four regions, of independent accounting and advisory businesses.
Wealth & Succession Points to Note
An owner and director of a 150-year-old Auckland iconic business, an Auckland accountant who has been building, guiding, and governing businesses for at least 35 years, and two second-generation (G2) [...]
Led by a purpose of saving lives and livelihoods
Argus Fire Protection designs solutions to protect life, property, and assets from fire. Founded in 1981 as a sprinkler contracting company, it consisted of a few old vans and a team of five [...]
There is no new normal – business principles
Times of exuberance and despair pass. Times where capital or labour is scarce also pass. The constant through all of this is that individually, all humans seek to maximise their utility. For some [...]
Tanya’s secrets to problem-solving
How do you solve a problem like Maria? You can send her to live with a widower and his seven children in Austria, but most problems aren’t that easy to solve. Quite often we’ll come across a [...]
Changes to domestic trusts
The IRD has introduced changes to the annual reporting requirement for domestic trusts for the 2022 income tax year onwards. The reasons for the changes are to better understand and monitor the use [...]
Change is good!
Don’t fear new systems, IT, or learning new things! If the past couple of years has taught us anything, it is that we need to adapt quickly to ensure our businesses keep going and to [...]
How to write an article
Hopefully by now, with this series on content marketing (you’ve just started reading #5) you’ve boarded the content marketing train. Content marketing answers your audience’s questions and [...]
Richard’s April 2022 – May 2022 tax updates
Richard has had over 30 years’ experience with New Zealand and International taxation. His team provide services including: Q&A service for accountants Tax opinions IRD risk reviews and audits [...]
Land and the bright-line test – a beginner’s guide
It’s always good practice to commence a guidance article like the one you are about to read, with a disclaimer and a warning. Firstly, the writer has prepared this document purely from the [...]
The future of money
The United States seems to be getting more and more dysfunctional. Social media bubbles are creating more radical views and domestic terrorism and then got Trump elected president. There’s been a [...]

Click here for details.

We are recognised as authorities in our specialised fields. We publish newsletters with informed opinions that are free for you to subscribe to.

Click here for details.

We are recognised as authorities in our specialised fields. We publish newsletters with informed opinions that are free for you to subscribe to.